The success of invasive macrophytes can depend on local nutrient availability and consumer pressure, which may interact. We therefore experimentally investigated the interacting effects of nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) addition, the exclusion of large herbivorous fishes and mimicked grazing on the expansion rates of the invasive seagrass Halophila stipulacea. The experiments were established on Bonaire and Aruba, two islands in the southern Caribbean, which differ in fish community structure. We observed that multiple Caribbean fish species feed on H. stipulacea. At both study sites, nutrient enrichment decreased invasive leaf carbon:nitrogen ratios. However only on Bonaire, where herbivore fish abundance was 7 times higher and diversity was 4.5 times higher, did nutrient enrichment result in a significant reduction of H. stipulacea expansion into native Thalassia testudinum meadows. This effect was likely due to increased herbivory on nutrient enriched seagrass leaves, as we found that excluding large herbivorous fish (e.g. parrotfish) doubled invasive expansion rates in bare patches on Bonaire. On Aruba, H. stipulacea expansion rates were higher overall, which coincided with lower abundances and diversity of native fishes, and were limited by mimicked fish grazing. We suggest that top-down control by the native fish community may counteract eutrophication effects by increased grazing pressure on nutrient-rich invasive seagrass leaves. We conclude that diverse and abundant herbivore communities likely play an important role in limiting invasion success and their conservation and restoration may serve as a tool to slow down seagrass invasions.

ABSTRACT: Juvenile queen conch are primarily associated with native seagrass such as Thalassia
testudinum in large parts of their range in the Caribbean and the southern Gulf of Mexico. Here,
a number of non-native seagrass species have been introduced including Halophila stipulacea,
which is natural to the Red Sea and the Indo-Pacific. In the Caribbean, H. stipulacea often creates
dense continuous mats with little or no sediment exposed, compared to native seagrass, which
grows much less dense. We examined the diet and growth of juvenile conch in both native, mixed,
and invasive seagrass beds using stable isotope analysis and an in situ growth enclosure experiment.
Organic material in the sediment (i.e. benthic diatoms and particulate organic matter) was
found to be the most important source of carbon and nitrogen for juvenile queen conch in all 3
habitats investigated, and there was a significantly higher probability of positive growth in the
native seagrass compared to the invasive seagrass. Due to the importance of the organic material
in the sediment as a source of nutrition for juvenile conch, limited access to the sediment in the
invasive seagrass can potentially cause inadequate nutritional conditions to sustain high growth
rates. Thus, it is likely that there is a negative effect on juvenile queen conch growth currently
inhabiting invasive seagrass beds, compared to native seagrass beds, when other potential
sources of nutrition are not available.